top of page

Jesuit Legal Theory and Ecumenical Reason of State: Aristotelian-Thomist Normativity, Colonial Enslavement, and the Genealogy of Indigenous Rights in the Early Modern Iberian Empires

Oct 28
8 min read

Updated: Oct 29


Research Abstract


This research project investigates how early modern Iberian scholasticism – principally articulated through the political and legal philosophy of the Society of Jesus and the School of Salamanca – constructed an ecumenical reason of state that simultaneously legitimised and critiqued imperial expansion, colonial dispossession, and unfree labor. Rather than denoting modern inter-confessional irenicism, ‘ecumenical reason of state’ specifies the supranational, universalist Catholic legal architecture through which Iberian thinkers articulated a trans-imperial normativity (respublica christiana), mediating between territorial state-building (ratio status) and universal natural jurisprudence.[1] Further, the research explores how law in the early modern Iberian empires cannot be understood solely as state statute (lex), but must be grasped through the dynamic friction between positive enactment and the broader, pluralistic normative universe of ius – encompassing natural jurisprudence, scholastic theology, customary rights, and institutional equity. Hence, law operated as a competitive, multi-layered nexus of normative knowledge where theological anthropology, natural jurisprudence, Aristotelian-Thomist philosophy, and colonial administrative decrees collided, drawing on the deep structural convergence between sacred authority and public law characteristic of early modern governance.[2] Still, this friction does not reduce lex to a static, monolithic command; rather, royal statutory codes were themselves casuistically negotiated and permeable, constantly re-articulated through the broader normative landscape of ius.


By mobilising an archaeological restructuring of the philosophical-legal-theological bases found in the doctrines of Francisco de Vitoria (1483–1546), Francisco Suárez (1548–1617), Domingo de Soto (1494–1560), Juan de Mariana (1536–1624), Bartolomé de Las Casas (1484–1566), and Luis de Molina (1535–1600)[3] – and their transmission through key colonial jurists such as Juan de Solórzano Pereira (1575–1655), Antonio de León Pinelo (1590–1660), and Fernando de Vázquez de Menchaca (1512–1566) – the project explores how normative frameworks adapted to conditions of Strong Asymmetrical Dependencies (SADs) in the global Iberian sphere. By interrogating the theological and legal architecture of justos títulos (just titles), the project argues that scholastic jurists attempted to reconcile universal natural jurisprudence with the concrete mechanics of territorial appropriation.[4] To achieve this, the research group integrates three multi-scalar tracks: (1) a Group Leader theoretical framework on ecumenical reason of state; (2) PhD Project 1 on the South American Jesuit reducciones; and (3) PhD Project 2 on the codification of unfree labour in Atlantic legal codes.

 

Theoretical Scope and Methodological Framework

The Genealogy of Normative Knowledge: From Scholasticism to Ecumenical Reason of State


The project departs from the premise that the early modern transition from medieval Christendom to sovereign imperial states was mediated by profound transformations in legal-theological thought. Law in the Iberian expansion was never a simple product of sovereign command (regula actionum civilium a majestate praescripta). Rather, it was the sedimented outcome of moral rectitude (honestas), customary practice, natural law (lex naturae), and casuistic theology.


In confronting the realities of transatlantic conquest, thinkers like Francisco de Vitoria (De Indis), Francisco Suárez (De legibus), Domingo de Soto (De iustitia et jure), and Luis de Molina (De iustitia et jure tractatus) faced a fundamental theoretical crisis: how to reconcile the universal natural rights articulated in Thomism with imperial expansion, indigenous subjugation, and transatlantic commerce. Drawing upon these foundational treatises – particularly Soto’s doctrine of restitution and Molina’s extensive analyses of commercial contracts – they resolved this by forging an ecumenical reason of state.[5] This stood for a universal, cross-border normative framework wherein religious orthodoxy, natural equity (epieikeia), and imperial utility were balanced to justify sovereignty while simultaneously generating internal doctrinal limits (such as the defence of indigenous rational capacity and natural liberties). Building upon Vitoria’s initial Relectiones, Molina extended scholastic jurisprudence into the global domain of Atlantic commerce and legal contracts, evaluating the legitimacy of chattel enslavement and state monopolies through the lens of casuistic moral theology.[6] As Thomas Duve has emphasised in his methodological framework on legal entanglements, this dynamic operationalised a pluralistic normative order across imperial spaces.[7]


This tension between universal natural jurisprudence (ius) and territorial statutory command (lex) reflects a fundamental restructuring of early modern political space, wherein scholasticism re-evaluated the normative boundaries of state jurisdiction and human nature.[8] By asserting the primacy of ius over sovereign statute, Iberian legal thinkers established an extra-territorial normative framework capable of both constraining and legitimising imperial authority across global horizons.


The Philological Method: Vis, Virtus, and the Dynamics of Normative Efficacy


At the heart of this framework lies the philological interplay between vis (coercive force/statutory efficacy) and virtus (normative power/functional capacity).[9] Grounded in classical lexicography (Politics, III.5), the project examines how scholasticism translated virtus into an active, normative efficacy applied directly to the force of law (vis legis). Imperial governance worked through the structural friction between vis directiva (moral/theological guidance) and vis compulsiva (statutory coercion). To explain how law kept binding force when enforcement was suspended in colonial contexts, the project excavates Suárez’s taxonomy of legal mutation:


Ab intrinseco (intrinsic cessation / cessatio): Where a law ceases to compel internally because its underlying reason (ratio) no longer applies, corresponding to situational equity (epieikeia).


Ab extrinseco (extrinsic withdrawal / ablatio): Where the sovereign directly suspends or removes an obligation via dispensation (dispensatio).[10] 


This distinction explains how imperial legal codes (Recopilación de las Leyes de Indias) remained doctrinally authoritative even when colonial administrators invoked the pragmatic maxim ‘obedezco pero no cumplo’ (‘I obey but I do not execute’), demonstrating how raw imperial force (vis) was continually mediated by normative power (virtus).[11] As Lewis Hanke proved in his classic studies on the Spanish struggle for justice, this systemic tension created a vital gap between royal statute and local enforcement in the Indies.[12] Crucially, this philological analysis does not sanitise the physical violence of colonial extraction; rather, it exposes how legal-theological categories (vis and virtus) functioned as active technologies of imperial discipline, attempting to legitimise regime structures of unfree labor and territorial dispossession.


[1] I have recently written on this phenomenon, see my forthcoming Nathaniel Boyd, ‘The History of Toleration: An Ecumenical Reason of State’, in Peter Schröder and Samuel Zeitlin (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Early Modern European Political Thought (Oxford: Oxford University Press, forthcoming 2028).

[2] Paolo Prodi, Il sacramento del potere: Il giuramento politico nella storia costituzionale dell’Occidente (Bologna: Il Mulino, 1992), pp. 1–25, 145–80. For the locus classicus on the intersection of public law and sacred authority, see Carl Schmitt, Roman Catholicism and Political Form, translated and annotated by George L. Ulmen (London: Bloomsbury, 1996).

[3] For primary editions and foundational historiographical frameworks on Spanish Scholasticism and natural law in the Indies, see Francisco de Vitoria, De Indis et de Iure Belli Relectiones, ed. Ernest Nys (Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Institution of Washington, 1917); Francisco Suárez, De Legibus, ac Deo Legislatore (Lyon: Horace Cardon, 1613 [1612]); Bartolomé de Las Casas, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies, ed. Nigel Griffin (London: Penguin, 1992); Anthony Pagden, The Fall of Natural Man: The American Indian and the Origins of Comparative Ethnology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982).

[4] See Francisco de Vitoria, ‘De Indis’ and ‘De Iure Belli’, in idem, Political Writings, edited by Anthony Pagden and Jeremy Lawrance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), pp. 233–292. ‘De Indis’ covers the critique of illegitimate titles and the formulation of legitimate titles, particularly in ibid., pp. 278–292 and pp. 293–327

[5] See Domingo de Soto, De iustitia et jure, libri decem (Salamanticae: Excudebat Joannes Maria a Terranova, 1556), Lib. IV, Q. 2–4 (on property, dominium, and natural liberty) and Lib. V, Q. 1–3 (on restitution). On the distinctiveness of Jesuit constitutionalism, popular sovereignty, and the internal limits placed on sovereign authority, see Harro Höpfl, Jesuit Political Thought: The Society of Jesus and the State, c. 1540–1630 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004), pp. 186–223, 263–282.

[6] Luis de Molina, De iustitia et jure tractatus, 6 volumes (Venice: Apud Sessas, 1614). For his foundational disputations on slave trading, contracts, and transatlantic commerce, see Tomus II, Disputationes 33–42 (‘De manumissione et servitute’) and Tomus II/III, Disputationes 345–410 (‘De contractibus’).

[7] Thomas Duve, ‘Entanglements in Legal History: Introductory Remarks’ and ‘European Legal History: Concepts, Methods, and Challenges’, in idem (ed.), Entanglements in Legal History: Conceptual Approaches (Frankfurt am Main: Max Planck Institute for European Legal History, 2014), pp. 3–26, 29–66.

[8] See Annabel Brett, Changes of State: Nature and the Limits of the City in Early Modern Natural Law (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2011), pp. 1–18, 130–45.

[9] Charlton T. Lewis, Elementary Latin Dictionary (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993), 924.

[10] See Suárez, De Legibus, ac Deo Legislatore, 385–6.

[11] Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales and Boletín Oficial del Estado (eds.), Recopilación de Leyes de los Reynos de las Indias, 4 vols, (Madrid: BOE/CEPC, 1998), Libro II, Título I, Ley XXII. On the procedural mechanics of ‘obedézcase pero no se cumpla’ as an instrument of situational equity (epieikeia) and jurisdictional suspension, see Francisco de Solano (ed.), Normas sobre el tratamiento del indio (Madrid: CSIC, 1991).

[12] Lewis Hanke, The Spanish Struggle for Justice in the Conquest of America (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1949), pp. 83–108, 133–155.



Objectives and Outputs


Project Group Leader Monograph Abstract: Ecumenical Reason of State. Jesuit Political Theory, Natural Jurisprudence, and Imperial Normativity 


This monograph establishes the theoretical and legal-historical foundation of the project. It posits that law in the early modern Iberian empires cannot be understood solely as state statute (lex), but must be grasped through the dynamic friction between positive enactment and the broader, pluralistic normative universe of ius – encompassing natural jurisprudence, scholastic theology, customary rights, and institutional equity. Mobilising an archaeological restructuring of doctrines from Francisco de Vitoria, Francisco Suárez, Domingo de Soto, Juan de Mariana, Bartolomé de Las Casas, and Luis de Molina – and their transmission through colonial jurists such as Juan de Solórzano Pereira, Antonio de León Pinelo, and Fernando de Vázquez de Menchaca – interrogating the theological and legal architecture of justos títulos (just titles) – the monograph demonstrates how scholastic jurists attempted to reconcile universal natural jurisprudence with the concrete mechanics of territorial appropriation exploring how normative frameworks adapted to conditions of intense asymmetrical dependencies across the global Iberian sphere. The monograph examines how theologians and jurists resolved the theoretical crisis of reconciling Thomist universal natural rights with transatlantic conquest. They forged an ecumenical reason of state – a universal, cross-border normative framework wherein religious orthodoxy, natural equity (epieikeia), and imperial utility were balanced to justify sovereignty while generating internal doctrinal limits on imperial power. Methodologically, the book excavates the philological interplay between vis (coercive force / statutory efficacy) and virtus (normative power / functional capacity). Grounded in classical lexicography (Politics, III.5) and Suárezian legal mutation (De legibus, ac Deo Legislatore), it demonstrates how the distinction between intrinsic cessation (cessatio / epieikeia) and extrinsic withdrawal (ablatio / dispensatio) allowed imperial legal codes (Recopilación de las Leyes de Indias) to maintain binding doctrinal authority even when local colonial authorities invoked the pragmatic administrative maxim ‘obedezco pero no cumplo’ (‘I obey but I do not execute’).

Doctoral  Sub-Project 1: Normative Entanglements and Indigenous Agency: The Guaraní Appropriation of the South American Jesuit Reducciones


Investigates the socio-legal structures of the Guaraní missions (reducciones), examining how missionary governance turned communitarian theology into an institutional buffer against encomienda exploitation while imposing a paternalistic normative regime. The study evaluates how these localised communitarian experiments prefigured modern notions of human rights, cultural autonomy, and early liberation theology. The primary sources to be analysed are the Archivo General de Indias (Seville), Archivo General de la Nación (Buenos Aires), and printed missionary reports (Cartas Anuas). Yet, in critically moving beyond both paternalist idealisations of ‘Jesuit utopias’ and narratives of total indigenous subjugation, Sub-Project 1 draws on recent post-colonial ethnohistory (e.g. Guillermo Wilde, Religión y Poder en Las Misiones Guaraníes (Buenos Aires: Editorial Sb, 2009); Julia Sarreal, The Guaraní and Their Missions: A Socioeconomic History (Stanford University Press, 2014)) to examine how Guaraní communities actively appropriated mission legal frameworks, municipal councils (cabildos de indios), and vernacular epistolary practices to negotiate local autonomy (teko porã) and resist inter-imperial violence.

Doctoral Sub-Project 2: The Aristotelian Legacy and the Codification of Unfree Labour: Strong Asymmetrical Dependencies in the Iberian Atlantic


Focuses on the legal-doctrinal mechanisms through which Spanish scholasticism formalised chattel slavery and coerced indigenous labour (mita, repartimiento). It examines how jurists and theologians reconciled the natural freedom of rational beings with the legal fictions of ‘just title’ (justos títulos) and natural slavery (servitus civilis versus servitus naturae), tracing how customary colonial practices hardened into statutory imperial codes. The primary sources to be examined are colonial legal codes, cedularios (Solano, Encinas), viceregal ordinances, and Council of the Indies consultation files (consultas).

Comments


bottom of page